In recent weeks The Guardian has published a series of letters (like this one and this one) from groups of individuals setting out positions on Zionism & antisemitism that are far removed from mainstream Jewish Labour perspectives.  

Of course the Guardian has every right to publish whichever letters it chooses. However, youth and student members of JLM submitted the following response to the paper setting out their own perspective. The Guardian has chosen, for its own reasons, not to balance the debate by publishing this letter.  Because of this, we are publishing it in full below.  Meanwhile, our question to The Guardian is why it is so selective about which groups of Jews it enables to express their views on its letters pages?  

Dear Editor,

We write as young members of the Labour Party and of the Jewish Labour Movement who are appalled by the recent trends of antisemitism in the Labour Party.

To see a Member of Parliament and a member of the Party’s ruling National Executive Committee suspended for making antisemitic comments and denying the offensive nature of comparing Hitler and the Nazis to the Zionist movement, has been extremely upsetting for us and many other Jewish members. the idea that accusations of antisemitism is merely a tool to smear the current leadership is quite simply wrong, and in our view, alienating to Jewish members and voters. Antisemitism exists within the Labour Party and must be taken seriously, instead of being dismissed and brushed aside.

But unfortunately, for many of us, this week has been nothing new. We know the difference between antisemitism and anti-Zionism, and right now both exist in abundance. The past few months have seen many of us having to contend with cases of antisemitism in university Labour Clubs, national youth elections and in the National Union of Students. Sadly, we are not surprised by these cases. For years, despite being party members from across the spectrum and with a range of views on domestic matters and on Israel/Palestine, we have all had experiences of being defined solely by our Jewish identity with our views ignored, and faced the use of loose antisemitic language such as ‘zio’ and ‘Zionist lobby’. At the same time, synagogues, Jewish schools and communal buildings all have high security due to the very real threat of violent antisemitic attacks. Antisemitism is not a theoretical problem, it is something we face in our daily lives. We do not want the Labour Party to become one more safe-haven for it.

Much has been written about the need for Jewish people to be able to define what is and isn’t antisemitism. This is hugely important if the Labour Party is to deal with this current crisis of antisemitism but when this current situation is over, we urge all Labour members to treat us like any other member with no prior assumptions and listen to our views as you would from anyone else, whether on domestic policy, on antisemitism or on Israel and Zionism.

Signed by Youth and Student members of the Jewish Labour Movement:

Charlie Agran
Rebecca Filer
Tommy Francies
BZ Gilinsky
Joe Grabiner
Daniel Katz
Jonathan Leader
Conor McGurran
Miriam Mirwitch
Eliana Neidich-Schwartz
Gabriel Phillips
Gabriel Pogrund
Ethan Schwartz
Aaron Simons
Miriam Steiner
Jay Stoll
Liron Velleman


The 'opinion' section of the JLM website is a space for debate and discussion.  All posts in the 'opinion' section of the JLM website reflect the opinion of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the policy, position, opinions or values of JLM.